Comments on: 100 Architects to Design City http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/ Green design & eco innovation for a better world Thu, 23 May 2013 21:03:05 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=abc By: Inhabitat » Miami Art Museum by Herzog & De Meuron http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-77820 Inhabitat » Miami Art Museum by Herzog & De Meuron Tue, 25 Mar 2008 20:37:56 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-77820 [...] were expecting an incredible design worthy of a cosmopolitan city such as Miami. What they got from Herzog & de Meuron can only be described as the modern interpretation of the Hanging Gardens of Babylon - an [...] [...] were expecting an incredible design worthy of a cosmopolitan city such as Miami. What they got from Herzog & de Meuron can only be described as the modern interpretation of the Hanging Gardens of Babylon – an [...]

]]> By: Design Shrine | blog wunderlust http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-77174 Design Shrine | blog wunderlust Sat, 15 Mar 2008 07:15:05 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-77174 [...] new continent: plastic | step right up - get your Gehry | DWR interviews Yves Béhar of Fuseproject | Watch out Gehry | Speed dating for Architects | posers | so small they left off the L|OFT | How many architects does it take to design a city: 100 [...] [...] new continent: plastic | step right up – get your Gehry | DWR interviews Yves Béhar of Fuseproject | Watch out Gehry | Speed dating for Architects | posers | so small they left off the L|OFT | How many architects does it take to design a city: 100 [...]

]]> By: Links for 2008-02-24 : 100 Architects, Hearst & YouTube, TV Ads, Reykjavik « Francis Anderson http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-76073 Links for 2008-02-24 : 100 Architects, Hearst & YouTube, TV Ads, Reykjavik « Francis Anderson Fri, 07 Mar 2008 10:53:11 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-76073 [...] 100 Architects to Design City That’s the challenge posed by Jian Yuan Water Engineering, which plans to create 100 villas in the city of Ordos, Inner Monglolia, comprised of 100 different designs by 100 up-and-coming architects. (tags: architecture design china future) [...] [...] 100 Architects to Design City That’s the challenge posed by Jian Yuan Water Engineering, which plans to create 100 villas in the city of Ordos, Inner Monglolia, comprised of 100 different designs by 100 up-and-coming architects. (tags: architecture design china future) [...]

]]> By: citicritter http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-75072 citicritter Sun, 02 Mar 2008 03:52:20 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-75072 SW, you are wrong on several counts: 1. you certainly didn't hurt my feelings. 2. these are not "large projects they will never realize in their own countries" -- this entails a single house per architect ; and BIG, Mass Studies Atelier Bow Wow among others have realized far bigger projects in their home countries (some of their countries being in Asia as well). 3. You presume to know "my generation", but you have no clue...In the end, as I said above, BAD or NO design is, as many people see it, one of the biggest problems behind the massive unchecked growth within parts of the developing world. SW, you are wrong on several counts: 1. you certainly didn’t hurt my feelings. 2. these are not “large projects they will never realize in their own countries” — this entails a single house per architect ; and BIG, Mass Studies Atelier Bow Wow among others have realized far bigger projects in their home countries (some of their countries being in Asia as well). 3. You presume to know “my generation”, but you have no clue…In the end, as I said above, BAD or NO design is, as many people see it, one of the biggest problems behind the massive unchecked growth within parts of the developing world.

]]> By: sw http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-74590 sw Thu, 28 Feb 2008 14:17:33 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-74590 I am sorry cc I didn't mean to hurt your feelings but ask an up and coming young Asian architect designer what he /she truly think about this and to be honest they will tell you exactly what you want to hear because the reality is really painful. These western firms treat China, Middle East and Central Asia as a colonial test bed for large projects they will never realise in their own countries and go all Oklahoma - there are serious repercussions for the communities they are designing for whom they do not have the time to get to know and there are catastrophic drawbacks as herzog and de meuron discovered to their displeasure when all your jobs are outsourced to china and india, the next generation who have as much flair and potential as yours, I think you'll finally get it So I maybe will leave the design profession to the 'others'. I am sorry cc I didn’t mean to hurt your feelings but ask an up and coming young Asian architect designer what he /she truly think about this and to be honest they will tell you exactly what you want to hear because the reality is really painful.

These western firms treat China, Middle East and Central Asia as a colonial test bed for large projects they will never realise in their own countries and go all Oklahoma – there are serious repercussions for the communities they are designing for whom they do not have the time to get to know and there are catastrophic drawbacks as herzog and de meuron discovered to their displeasure

when all your jobs are outsourced to china and india, the next generation who have as much flair and potential as yours, I think you’ll finally get it

So I maybe will leave the design profession to the ‘others’.

]]> By: citicritter http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-74102 citicritter Tue, 26 Feb 2008 16:23:45 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-74102 Not all architects are "part of the problem". If that's your feeling, sw, leave the design profession to others. Bad or no design is a major part of the problem of sprawling development all around the globe. QingYun Ma just lectured in SF last night (yeah, I'm from the Bay Area, hence my being psyched about the inclusion of an SF architect on a list like this that's typically all NY/LA for the US) , and he spoke about the reality of how buildings at all scales in China are a such a product of massive amounts of hand labor; having little or no design involved is not going to alter that fact. Plus who said these architects have an "unlimited budget"? And they certainly won't have unlimited materials in Inner Mongolia. As for the slave labor comment: that's BS -- I'm sure local laborers there will be happy to have the work. You might as well indict all of China's progress while you're at it. Sure, there are issues regarding the massive development in China and its environmental impact, but the scale of this project is a drop in the bucket, with at least (we can assume) decent design quality resulting from the effort. Maybe someone in the 100 will do a yurt...will that make you happy, sw? Not all architects are “part of the problem”. If that’s your feeling, sw, leave the design profession to others. Bad or no design is a major part of the problem of sprawling development all around the globe.

QingYun Ma just lectured in SF last night (yeah, I’m from the Bay Area, hence my being psyched about the inclusion of an SF architect on a list like this that’s typically all NY/LA for the US) , and he spoke about the reality of how buildings at all scales in China are a such a product of massive amounts of hand labor; having little or no design involved is not going to alter that fact.

Plus who said these architects have an “unlimited budget”? And they certainly won’t have unlimited materials in Inner Mongolia. As for the slave labor comment: that’s BS — I’m sure local laborers there will be happy to have the work. You might as well indict all of China’s progress while you’re at it. Sure, there are issues regarding the massive development in China and its environmental impact, but the scale of this project is a drop in the bucket, with at least (we can assume) decent design quality resulting from the effort.

Maybe someone in the 100 will do a yurt…will that make you happy, sw?

]]> By: sw http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-74075 sw Tue, 26 Feb 2008 12:13:45 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-74075 Excited? yet another grand masterplan for the rich and powerful - congratulations to the architects involved with an unlimited budget, materials and slave labour you can create heaven on earth when are we as architects going to realise that we are part of the problem? Excited?

yet another grand masterplan for the rich and powerful – congratulations to the architects involved with an unlimited budget, materials and slave labour you can create heaven on earth

when are we as architects going to realise that we are part of the problem?

]]> By: citicritter http://inhabitat.com/100-architects-to-design-a-city/comment-page-1/#comment-73980 citicritter Mon, 25 Feb 2008 20:49:13 +0000 http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/02/23/100-architects-to-design-a-city/#comment-73980 This is exciting -- some great architects involved: Mass Studies, BIG, Atelier Bow-Wow, R&Sie, NL Architects, Rojkind, Aravena, Tatiana Bilbao, LTL, nArchitects, JohnstonMarklee, Teddy Cruz, MOS, WORK and IwamotoScott representin SF no less!. This is exciting — some great architects involved: Mass Studies, BIG, Atelier Bow-Wow, R&Sie, NL Architects, Rojkind, Aravena, Tatiana Bilbao, LTL, nArchitects, JohnstonMarklee, Teddy Cruz, MOS, WORK and IwamotoScott representin SF no less!.

]]>