Comments on: Architects Envision Hawaii-Sized Island Made of Recycled Plastic

By: joulesofthesea

joulesofthesea — Thu, 29 Mar 2012 01:50:43 +0000

The concept is an idealistic/optimistic perhaps even a /naive one. However we have a multiple battlefront war here not just a one front war. As far as the part of the battlefront you are addressing in this island plan you would just be putting a bandage on the wound and making it less visible is all. By making the problem less visible without addressing ALL of the other problems you may speed up the death of the ocean and not save it at all.

Putting makeup over skin cancer will not cure it. All you will accomplish is to make it less visible until it eventually metastasizes and likely kills you. The trash in the ocean is a cancer that is starting to metastasize. We need to address the cancer, attack it aggressively but intelligently, and remove it all. But we also have to do everything we can to stop it from occurring or reoccurring again. Get involved now by visiting and supporting organizations like http://5gyres.org/ and get out of the plastic habit.
~~Joules of the Sea~~

PS. Hoping to make a trash run in 2013 to test a design similar to the trash manta net but need to find some funding first. Fingers crossed!

By: feline74

feline74 — Wed, 29 Jun 2011 10:46:33 +0000

As luck and/or irony would have it, a lot of this stuff tends to accumulate near Hawaii! If the means of harvesting and recycling it exists, using it to fuel a Hawaiian plastics industry would probably make the less tourist-friendly islanders quite happy.

By: Snowmeow

Snowmeow — Fri, 20 Aug 2010 20:36:22 +0000

In the world of today, any idea is a valuable idea. Only thing needed is money to sponsor these initiatives.

it is still a concept, and many things can change as people begin to take out their butts from their comfortable couches and begin doing something useful.

By: nadine sellers

nadine sellers — Sun, 25 Jul 2010 15:16:31 +0000

one word, tsunami..float and sink..assuming that the construction would be handled the same way the netherland were built and continue to operate..it is remotely possible to form a nucleus basic structure and add on as commercial sins surface…a rest from excess..on a temporary solution.
as long as new inhabitants realize that they are a migrating specie on a consumer penitential hiatus.

By: louisjohn9

louisjohn9 — Sat, 10 Jul 2010 09:32:08 +0000

here are billions of pounds of plastic moving out in the ocean and the someone way to use charge of it would be to accumulate it all and reprocess it. Thought Structure, from the Netherlands, is proposing to do fitting that with their Recycled Island – due the impressible, form it and then utilize it into construction blocks to create a whole new floating island as big as Hawaii (some 10,000 sq km) depending on how more plastic could be collected. As the status changes, numerous grouping, especially island nations similar the State, faculty be affected from their homes, decent refugees. The new island, situated somewhere between San Francisco and Hawaii would be made open to those refugees.

By: Been To Gyre

Been To Gyre — Sat, 08 May 2010 15:38:12 +0000

Do you know how frustrating it is to sail across an ocean studying plastic debris with a team of scientists and photographers and then come back and offer all those media assets for free to blogs like Inhabitat, hoping that finally, finally, the media will quit perpetuating the myth that you can A.) collect this stuff in some meaningful way B.) That’s it’s an island the size o texas C.) That anyone would want to live on island made of something that attracts pollutants like a sponge? Do you understand that post like this give people false hope? Do you understand that plastic pollution in the ocean is like 100 gulf spills over and over again? Do you understand that posts like this help the ACC keep making the crap that is literally killing the ocean?

By: luckybastard

luckybastard — Mon, 03 May 2010 09:06:31 +0000

hey guys the project is great, but you can show off better with just a little help, i make 3d rendering and animations, here’s my email for estimates, juarez.guillermo@hotmail.com

By: blim micky

blim micky — Sun, 02 May 2010 02:24:58 +0000

ok, here is my idea!
take all the worstest things in the world and use them to do all the latest cool-sounding best things!

this will work, because as you know, the two extremes of a spectrum actually connect to each other to form a circle. see: magenta, and the notion “so bad it’s good”

forget those processes branded “best” by the eco-regime have hardly been implemented in isolation on pre-existing land, let alone in stunning integrated concert on land made from the excess of the spoiled industrialized spoils of our chapped baby butts.

using technology sourced from the movie Water World, we are now capable of placing the defecations of total strangers into a holy holey blackbox. Turn your back for a mere mirror 48 hours and you’ll be surprised to find the box has produced its own food, elegantly handled the sticky logistics of waste management, and now is successfully harnessing energy from anything exhibiting kinetic motion within 10 square kilometers. The box, being principally made of fertilizer, can serve as fertilizer! That means you can grow food, eat food, poop poop, feed the box poop, and get more food to eat and poop and eat!

What if something grows that doesn’t look edible? Well, it’s still /something/ isn’t it? We’ve found that anything that’s something is surprisingly multipurpose, capable of being transformed (or “digivolving”) into food, biofuel, fertilizer, medicine, and CO2 absorption.

’cause, y’know, it’s CO2′s fault we began thinking like this in the first place.

there’s a fat line between things you think up in the bathroom (the toilet/twilight zone) and comprehensive design. this proposal may have some kernel of cool idea in it, but they really sunk the ship by rolling their concept like a katamari ball through the fields of blogospheric buzzwords.

all of this critique equally applies to me.

By: davidwayneosedach

davidwayneosedach — Fri, 16 Apr 2010 00:27:44 +0000

What a constructive idea! Use the trash to make something beautiful and useful.

By: kristiantheconqueror

kristiantheconqueror — Wed, 14 Apr 2010 04:56:03 +0000

I’m not sure which is funnier – the entire implausibility of this idea (collecting all the plastic garbage in the pacific will be horrifically wasteful of energy,) the incredible lack of research or the hilariously amateurish photoshop job in the “renderings”.