Art or Animal Abuse? Tortoises Carry iPads for Controversial New Exhibition in Aspen

by , 08/08/14
filed under: Animals, Art, Design, Environment, News

The Aspen Art Museum (AAM) hasn’t even officially opened its doors to the public yet, but one of its exhibitions is already causing massive controversy. Cai Guo-Qiang’s installation Moving Ghost Town features three African Sulcata tortoises roaming around a rooftop enclosure, each with two iPads affixed to its shell. The gadgets display video footage of local ghost towns. The AAM claims the artwork is “cultivating a site-specific approach to culture and history,” but animal rights activists have slammed it as outright animal abuse. What do you think?

The museum’s webpage for the project is short on exhibition motivation and long on describing what has been done to ensure the tortoises’ welfare. The purpose of the exhibition is summarized as such: “The tortoises feature video footage of three local ghost towns, which were filmed by the creatures themselves. Forgotten stories of the once prosperous ghost towns are retold from the tortoises’ perspective.”

Related: Conservationists Scar Shells to Protect Endangered Tortoises

The exhibition officially runs from 9 August to 5 October, 2014, a two-month period during which the three adult tortoises will each carry around their two iPads. The devices will be affixed to their shells using a technique usually used to mount tracking equipment for scientific study of wild turtles and tortoises and that leaves no trace on the shells after removal. The three tortoises were all rescued from a breeder who had kept them in an over-crowded enclosure. And after the exhibition, the AAM says they “will find new homes in conservation and educational facilities selected in collaboration with the Turtle Conservancy.”

However, it’s from about this point in the story that views begin to diverge wildly. On Tuesday 5 August, Aspen native Lisabeth Oden began an online petition addressed to the AAM that begins quite simply with the words: “We, the undersigned, request you end this animal abuse.” The petition highlights the sensitivity of the animals’ carapaces, which would make carrying around the devices for two months distressing for the creatures. At time of writing the petition had received over 3,400 signatures. The AAM counters this request by stating that the animals are under veterinary supervision and that a vet and the Turtle Conservancy were consulted during the exhibition’s development.

Related: Shigeru Ban Unveils Spectacular Daylit Aspen Art Museum!

The Turtle Conservancy were quickly at pains to point out that they “did not approve or endorse the installation at the Aspen Art Museum. We were merely asked to give them advice on the captive care of African Spurred Tortoises.” In a further and measured statement a spokesperson for the Turtle Conservancy confirmed the scientific precedent of the method used to affix the iPads to the tortoises without apparent harm, noted that during mating female tortoises bear the load of a 250+ pound male tortoise on their backs, and wrote “I honestly believe that these animals do not even notice the extra weight on their shells after living with the accoutrements for 24 hours.”

But in a personal statement the spokesperson added that tortoise mating does not go on nonstop for two months. He noted: “Attaching for scientific purposes is one thing. There is a positive gain for research. This is merely for human entertainment.” And that’s the sticking point. Even if the tortoises’ welfare is guaranteed, it doesn’t automatically follow that the installation is a good idea. As one angry commentator out of many on the AAM’s Facebook page noted: “This isn’t art, this is a way of gaining publicity. I don’t think you realized how bad the publicity would be.”

+ Aspen Art Museum


Via Fast Company

Photos via Aspen Art Museum and

Related Posts


or your inhabitat account below


  1. Cindy Jencks November 23, 2014 at 6:15 am

    Why not just a small camera that just sat up on top? Why two great big ipads? It looks like they screwed it into the shell. They say it doesn’t damage the turtle but I don’t believe it. I see screws. We have abused, exploited, eaten and shot for sport animals into extinction. Those animals need a voice and that is us.

  2. Falling September 18, 2014 at 3:17 am

    I don’t think that this is a very cool thing to do, and I say this as the proud shell-mommy of two Redfoot tortoises who were rescues with terrible damage done to them when I got them. However, I was relieved to know that the iPads were not damaging to the shells, because from the picture, it looked like someone had -screwed- the things -into- the shells, and when I saw that, I started to feel like I was going to hurl. If you’ve never petted a tortoise before, you would probably be pleasantly surprised to know that their shells are rather sensitive, and they do react with affection when you pet/rub their shells. I hope that this is stopped soon, regardless. We already have such a decline of turtles, tortoises, and terrapins worldwide; couldn’t they have found better/more willing subjects for their little project, you know…like…humans? Heck, put it on a battery-powered toy car; just leave the poor shell-babies out of it!

  3. Gönül Çelik August 11, 2014 at 3:54 am

    It is creative…. and abusive for the poor turtles also. But this also the main story of the homo sapiens isnt\\\’it ? To use everything for satisfaction of their huge egos. I don t know how those artist woud feel if two screens as bid as their back would attached to their shoulders or bellies like those turtles . And walk around nine hours for the artistic reasons.

  • Read Inhabitat

  • Search Categories

  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

  • Browse by Keyword

get the free Inhabitat newsletter

Submit this form
popular today
all time
most commented
more popular stories >
more popular stories >
more popular stories >
Federated Media Publishing - Home