We’re a little ban-happy. Some bans are easy to defend. For example, most of us like it when harmful chemicals, such as BPA are banned. On the flip side, not everyone is on board with banning kids from cell phones or the Happy Meal Toy bans. Now though, Happy Meals and cell phones may be the least of our ban worries. In what’s sure to become a huge debate if it passes, is a newly proposed ban on male baby circumcision. This new measure was submitted by San Francisco resident Lloyd Schofield.

If this proposed ballot measure makes it to the November 2011 ballot, it will amend The City’s police codeto make it a misdemeanor to circumcise, excise, cut or mutilate the foreskin, testicle or penis of another person who has not attained the age of 18.” Schofield, a long-time advocate against baby circumcision, needs to collect more than 7,100 signatures in order to get this circumcision ban on the ballot. Until this does or doesn’t happen, I’m sure we’ll be hearing plenty from both advocates for and against baby circumcision.

Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.


baby boy be circumcised, circumcised babies, Circumcision cons, Circumcision pros, Male Circumcision, Medical Ethics, Parenting, San Francisco, how common is circumcision, should you circumcise, Ballot Initiative, Circumcision, Circumcision Ban, Foreskin, Lloyd Shofield

The pros and cons of circumcision alone would take us pages to discuss, so we won’t be doing that now. Both sides of the circumcision debate have research and highly emotionally charged arguments for their respected side — and that’s without even touching on the religious aspects. As everyone argues the pros and cons though, no one can argue stats. The CDC notes that there has been an increasingly sharp drop in the number of American parents who choose circumcision for their baby boys. In 2006 56% of baby boys in America were circumcised, while last year the numbers dropped to just 33% of baby boys.

baby boy be circumcised, circumcised babies, Circumcision cons, Circumcision pros, Male Circumcision, Medical Ethics, Parenting, San Francisco, how common is circumcision, should you circumcise, Ballot Initiative, Circumcision, Circumcision Ban, Foreskin, Lloyd Shofield

Personally, I’m on the fence when it comes to an official ban, because where might it all end? Would the government then force us to vaccinate, even if we didn’t want to? Would homeschooling be banned? Would all women be forced to breastfeed no matter what? A ban on circumcision may open some forced parenting doors that we don’t want opened.

That said, my son was born in 2001. Back then more than 60% of all baby boys were regularly circumcised. However, I never considered circumcision for my son; not even for a second. How come? Because why on earth would I cut a body part off of my son that he was born with and expose my baby to pain without a medical reason to do so? While yes, I’m on the fence about an official ban, I can say that I don’t see a good reason to have your baby circumcised unless there is a valid medical reason to have the procedure done.

Tell us what you think? Are you going to circumcise your baby OR did you already circumcise your son? Why? Do you support the ban on circumcision or not?

[images via sxc]