Jane Birkin has asked HermĂ¨s to remove her name from one of its most iconic bags following a People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals investigation into the farming methods of some of its crocodile- and alligator-skin suppliers. “Having been alerted to the cruel practices reserved for crocodiles during their slaughter to make HermĂ¨s’s handbags carrying my name… I have asked HermĂ¨s’s to de-baptize the Birkin Croco until better practices in line with international norms can be put in place,” the British actress and fashion icon told AFP.
A report released by PETA last month featured undercover video recorded at Zimbabweâ€™s Padenga Holdings, one of the largest Nile crocodileâ€“farming operations in the world, as well as Lone Star Alligator Farms in Winnie, Texas. Both facilities provide HermĂ©s-owned tanneries with skins for the luxury house’s high-end wares, according to the animal-rights group, noting that it takes two or three crocodiles to make just one of the coveted handbags.
PETAâ€™s video reveal a tableau of cruelty. Farm workers are seen stabbing conscious reptiles to dislocate their vertebrae, or sawing them open and skinning them while they’re still alive.
“PETA, on behalf of all kind souls in the world, thanks Ms. Birkin for ending her association with HermĂ¨s, which makes grotesque handbags that were revealed in a PETA exposĂ© to be constructed from the skins of factory-farmed and cruelly slaughtered crocodiles,” PETA founder Ingrid Newkirk said in response to Birkin’s statement. “We call on HermĂ¨s to stop plundering wildlife, factory-farming crocodiles and alligators and slaughtering them for their skins.
Costing upwards of $10,000, and beloved by the elite, the Birkin is arguably the biggest status symbol you can tote on your arm. Newkirk says she’s hopeful that the sentiment will change, however.
“Once, Birkin bags marked people as celebrities or at least members of the super-rich, but soon, no one will want to be caught dead carrying one, and animal advocates will then breathe a sigh of relief,” she said.
HermĂ¨s, for its part, has denied that the farms in the video belong to it, or that the skins are used to make Birkin bags. Yet it promises an investigation is underway.
“HermĂ¨s imposes on its partners the highest standards in the ethical treatment of crocodiles. For more than 10 years, we have organized monthly visits to our suppliers,” the company said in a statement. “Any breach of rules will be rectified and sanctioned.”
Update: Sept. 15, 2015
British Vogue reports that Birkin has repaired her rift with HermĂ¨s, noting that she’s “satisfied” by the measures taken by the brand.
But PETA isn’t buying whatever HermĂ¨s is selling. “Jane Birkin is a good person, and we think she has been given false assurances by HermĂ¨s that it gives a hoot about animals or that what PETA witnessed was â€“ so convenientlyâ€”an aberration in the way that it factory-farms and slaughters crocodiles and alligators,” PETA founder Ingrid Newkirk said in a statement.
“The appalling conditions that PETA exposed are not an ‘isolated irregularity,’ at all,” she added. “In the month that PETA’s investigator was employed at the Lone Star Alligator Farm’s abattoir in Texas, no inspectors were on site nor was there any mention of inspections, casting grave doubt on HermĂ¨s’ assurances that it conducts monthly inspections. Had HermĂ¨s personnel looked, they would have seen alligators crowded into dark, filthy pits full of alligator waste and grossly inhumane methods used to kill the reptilesâ€”yet nothing was done about it.”
PETA says it’s hopeful that Birkin will see the light. “We believe Ms Birkin will come to realize that her good name does not belong on a bag made from the cruelly obtained skins of factory-farmed wildlife,” Newkirk said.