The gap-toothed first mateys among your crew will be wide-eyed over Oeuf’s shiny, new gold tooth fairy pillow. The cheery molar-shaped pillow is a real treasure that can contain a little skipper’s gem of a tooth while waiting for the infamous fairy to stake her claim. Pirates in training will lose their anchors over the new-found booty deposited in the pillow’s pocket. Just don’t let on that this knit toy is a real softie — made from luxurious, hypoallergenic 100% baby alpaca in Bolivia by a self-managed community of indigenous women, under Fair Trade principles — or you’re likely to walk the plank.

+ Oeuf Gold Tooth Fairy Pillow $32

+ Oeuf