Gallery: Study Finds Wind Farm “Sickness” is Largely a Propaganda-Induc...

 

Claims of illnesses related to the presence of wind farms have spread throughout Australia lately like a bad high school rumor. While many believe they are experiencing a real sickness, a report by Simon Chapman from the University of Sydney has found that victims may be suffering more from a psychological illusion than a true physical malady. The study found evidence that areas targeted by anti-wind farm groups and propaganda were far more likely to express symptoms.

Chapman’s report was the first to formally address the issue of wind farm illness in Australia. He saw that complaints of illness were more prevalent in areas that had been bombarded with false information by wind farm opponents. He saw that 63% of the population had not been subject to health or noise aggravations, and in Western Australia, a region that has 13 wind farms, no problems were recorded. He found 68% of the total number of complaints came from five sites that had been heavily targeted by anti-wind farm groups since 2009.

“If wind farms were intrinsically unhealthy or dangerous in some way, we would expect to see complaints applying to to all of them, but in fact there is a large number where there have been no complaints at all,” said Chapman.

According to his research, the bias against wind farms began two decades ago when the country started to install the turbines. Some just didn’t like the way the equipment looked, and began using names like “wind turbine syndrome” and “vibro-acoustic disease” to cast a negative light on the turbines. While he accepts that some people could have actually felt ill, he noted that “where you set up an expectation in people that something in their environment is noxious, that can translate into the expression of symptoms”.

His results run counter to the opinions of the anti-wind farm group, the Waubra Foundation, which asserts that serious conditions have been found to occur in those living or working 6 miles of wind turbines. The organization says that the syndrome’s symptoms manifest as hypertension, insomnia, heart attacks, and depression. The Foundation believes that the wind farms are creating human collateral damage, and that denial of the population’s suffering is the industry’s refusal to acknowledge an “inconvenient truth”.

Yet, Chapman states that if the technology was truly harmful, there would be a large body of supporting medical evidence. In eighteen reviews of health since 2003, all had reached the consensus that there was scant support to prove wind farms were harmful. He mentioned a New Zealand study that exposed 60 healthy subjects to real and false low frequency samples of noise similar to that produced by turbines. They showed a portion of the volunteers videos suggesting that illnesses were caused by the equipment before listening to the sounds, and only those shown the tapes reported higher levels of symptoms regardless of whether they listened to fake or real recordings.

+ University of Sydney

Via the Guardian

Images via Wikicommons users Fir0002 and Cyr

LEAVE A COMMENT

or your inhabitat account below

Let's make sure you're a real person:


3 Comments

  1. camackenzie November 29, 2013 at 11:07 pm

    Nocebo effect. If you believe a pill is harming you, you get sick. If you believe a witch is hexing you, you get sick. And, if you believe the windmill creates bad vibrations…

  2. ronwagn March 21, 2013 at 2:12 pm

    Good to see some serious study on this. I would like more partidulars regarding how close they should be, and just how annoying they can be. Annoyance can affect the enjoyment of life, property values etc. Some people also consider wind farms and solar panels to be serious visual blight. I do not. Does anyone have polls on that and NIMBY opinions?

  3. donrolando March 21, 2013 at 12:42 pm

    i fing it interesting that wind mills do not slow down when they put energy into the grid…donrolando.com/myspace

get the free Inhabitat newsletter

Submit this form
popular today
all time
most commented
more popular stories >
more popular stories >
more popular stories >
What are you looking for? (Solar, HVAC, etc.)
Where are you located?